Musical-Memoirs's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[{Meinsla} Elysium]

great

wow this one is nice!!!
there is not much i could give bad critics on, the things i could give on are just because those parts are a little different style then i prefer, so its not even important to mention
only i would probably make a part in it where i played a little with the main melody to make it in that part more advanced (only the idea i have might sound great in my head, but in reality it might be too hard or not sound so well)
guess i even favorite this one

also everyone has a different way of creating songs... mine are sometimes finished in short time too... i get a burst of inspiration and i can make something nice very fast... but once i loose my inspiration i get stucked and then i can spent days on it without getting any progress...
~K4P~ 22 - sunshine (after the rain) was finished in 3 hours because i had a giant burst of inspiration... but when i wanted to do things on it later to improve it more nothing happened, every try to make it better failed because i lost my inspiration to continue on the same project...
the first 3 hours were with inspiration and created 95% of the song... the next (i think i spent around) 6 hours trying to improve without my burst of inspiration gave only a little 5% of the songs progress

but there might always be some people who wants to show of by saying how less time they need to make something... so they might lie or not count some time they spend for the preparation for the project like the time you need to find the right synths... most people spend a hell lot of time to create something simple, just like you do... dont let others who might even lie about it make you feel less good or fast!

Kill4Peace

meinsla responds:

Thanks man, your reviews mean a lot to me. Glad you liked it. :)

[~Inspiration~ -hania]

great!!!

i love it, this kind of music is really something i like to listen to
and you performed it quite nicely... but there are points it still can improve on

you have a great voice, even though its great and has a lot of feelings in the words, i still think you could sing some part that it fits the song better
"We're chasing the world on fire" (1.19) the way you sing "fire" in that part fits great, it gives a fantasy feeling to the words... wish you did that more!!!

and something that can be improved on the instruments is the string-like sound from 1.36
if you used some realistic sounding strings instead of the ones that are in it now then it would definitely give an epic feeling to the second part!!!
also the music doesn't reach its full potential in some other parts...

keep it up!!! you sure have talent...
good luck

[Call it Love - Champius Rmx]

nicely done!

checked the original...
and you really made great improvements
this remix has so much more variation and everything in it fits
gonna check more from you

[Ideal (NG Mix)]

nice

i like the style of this song
i like the outro a lot and the intro aint bad either... and the rest is also great
(only it feels to far extended after listening a few times in a row, even though it has quite a lot of variation in it)

[Piano song working title/demo]

definitely a demo, could be done a lot

it has great potential but doesnt reach it yet, good luck on it
you should at least make the piano louder and let the melody more evolve into a more advanced melody like you did at 0:26

[Jo-Light Sticks]

great!!!

its great, im happy to see 2 new good sounding tracks after not checking for very long
this song is really great, its perfect except for a few unnecessary seconds
the vocals at 1:26 really bugs me a lot, i dont understand what went though your mind when you placed them in it
it irritates me so much that i will cut them out after i downloaded this song

[Mt.Goat - Wonderwall Piano]

nice

normally i dont like it when people just simply make piano versions of famous song. but after all i prefer it when people create their own songs without any or at least low use of already existing songs
but it does sound nice, and it feels like you put a lot of time in it anyway
so its still worth a 8 to me ;P

[oMinouS dancefloor (cool song)]

totally not my style

its totally not my style...
but the way its created, the melody, the synths and things like that makes it nice and special
its something nice... but its so much not my style that i probably wont listen it ever again
but still its worth a 9 XD

[Lullaby (Game music)]

almost

great idea and melody!!!

but the quality should be better, it feels too much sampled
especially the strings, they feel unrealistic and are a little disturbing because of that
you used the same samples over and over, wich make them loose their feelings and makes the strings feel unconnected...
good luck!!!

C-Storm responds:

Yeah. its because if I use to many different strings I get screechy noises.. But it will improve as soon as I get a 64-bit OS and can use all my RAM.

[the Composer]

cant stop listening/watching :D

http://jazza.newgrounds.com/news/post /32332
he already made a sheet for us
on this news post of him you can get it